Unless you’ve been under a rock, you know that President-elect Barack Obama has designated former rival Hillary Clinton to be Secretary of State. I have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, I think she will make a great S of S. On the other hand, I think this marks the pinnacle of her political career and in a few years, the end. In so many ways, I wish she had remained the Senator from New York, as I feel her abililty to accomplish her stated goals for America would have been easier there.
LATEST FROM VPBPOPULAR POSTS
Most viewed (last 30 days)- Sideshow Bob: time to resign
- Pilot - and Portsmouth council - fed up with sheriff's antics
- The struggle toward inclusiveness
- Hester for Mayor: "It's time"
- Coffee Party
- Male vs female, white vs black
- Nikki Giovanni: "We are Virginia Tech
- Get over it? Yeah, right (part 2)
- A look at the minimum wage
- Smoking ban
- AP POLITICAL NEWS
- LATEST FROM BNN VA
- NORFOLK.GOV NEWS
- Check out the new Lamberts Point Community Center and participate in a youth forum. Ages 13-17.
- National Mental Health Experts to Speak at Norfolk Forum
- See plans for new Crossroads Elementary. $29 million school funded through City CIP Budget.
- Keep children safe with upcoming Internet safety workshop
- Practice Tornado Safety
- LATEST FROM BAR
- LATEST FROM HRB
LEGAL
Vivian J. Paige Copyright © 2006 - 2009. All rights reserved. No part of Vivian J. Paige maybe used without the express written consent of Vivian J. Paige. For more information, contact Vivian J. Paige.
WELCOME
I started this blog to talk about local politics, specifically Norfolk politics. It is impossible
to talk about Norfolk in a vacuum, so you'll also find some regional, state, and national politics. And sometimes, no politics at all.
The inspiration for this blog comes from one of Virginia's most respected forefathers:
"I know no safe depositary of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves; and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise their control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education. This is the true corrective of abuses of constitutional power."
Thomas Jefferson, 1820
I hope you enjoy your visit!
If you are new here, please review my comment policy.
17 Comments
Don’t you think she’ll have more of an impact as Secretary of State than as the Junior Senator for New York ?
Actually, no, I don’t think so.
But think about it this way.
Given how far down in the ranks of seniority she is, and the fact that most of the people in front of her are unlikely to leave the Senate in any manner other than feet first, it’s pretty unlikely that she’d be moving up the leadership ladder anytime soon.
She wouldn’t be able to run in 2012, and she’ll likely be considered too old in 2016.
It’s an Arnie Vinick all over again.
I’m not thinking about advancing her political career. I’m thinking about her advocacy for the domestic issues that she put forth during her campaign.
(And 2008 was her only shot at the presidency – she’s 60 already.)
Perhaps you will still get your wish. Someone of political influence and respect for the U.S. Constitution may yet discover that Senator Clinton is prohibited from being confirmed. See Article 1 Section 6 U.S. Constitution (emoluments clause). More on my post here:
http://the.virginianfederalist.com/2008/11/hillary-ineligible-for-secretary-of.html.
One may also think that the appointment of Susan Rice as U.N. ambassador and elevation to cabinet rank may be intended to keep Mrs. Clinton in a gilded but stout cage.
Actually, I understand that the way around that problem is to reduce the salary. So I think that one will be moot.
And the Rice appointment is another reason I’d just as soon Hillary had stayed in the Senate.
There was an article last week that made the point that any effort on her part to take the lead on issues like health care would have been fruitless given that more senior Senators — Ted Kennedy being one — have already taken the lead on that topic.
It’s called the Saxby fix, and Richard Nixon used it back in the 1970s.
But, there’s a pretty credible argument from one law professor that the Saxby fix doesn’t get around the problem:
http://tinyurl.com/6ntxan
Strictly read, the Emoluments Clause would seem to bar Clinton from serving, but I doubt it will ever come to that.
Vivian, I consider what Hillary Clinton did, in accepting the post of Sec. of State, in the best patriotic interest of our nation and the world … she has proven once again that she is an awesome force never to be underestimated … I feel relatively certain her voice in the cabinet will advance her many causes more than if she had remained a Senator from NY … and we will all be better for her contributions
Doug – articles notwithstanding, I think Hillary would have been a force to reckon with in the Senate. She’s earned it.
And Shawn, I don’t think her serving in the cabinet will advance her causes, especially not the domestic ones. Everyone has to stay in their own lanes.
Vivian,
Nonetheless, she accepted the job.
Which may be an indication that she thinks she can contribute more as Secretary of State and that the domestic issues she campaigned on aren’t as important to her as she led supporters to believe.
Doug – that doesn’t change what I think. And it doesn’t change the fact that I wish she had stayed in the Senate.
With you completely on the substance of the original post. She’ll be a fine SoS, but I really wish she’d remained in the Senate. Ah well.
A snake in th white house be careful mr. presdient always look backward have food tasters.
If Hillary (or Bill) gets out of line she can be asked to resign or be fired.
As a Senator the voters could have kept sending her back in there.